© 2019 Oldham Insurance Agency  |  All Rights Reserved  |  Privacy Policy

CARRIERS

With access to several of the largest and most respected companies, we are confident we can find the best coverage and rates for you. Use the links below to see more information about a company.

 

We would prefer that you contact us first for claims at 317-328-4444. In the event that we are unavailable and/or it is outside of our business hours, below are the phone numbers for after-hours claims.

Auto-Owners Logo

Phone:

Auto-Owners Insurance

Claims:

517.323.1200

888.252.4626

Alfa Alliance Insurance Logo

Phone:

Alfa Alliance Insurance

855.253.2242

AmTrust Financial Logo

Phone:

AmTrust Financial

Claims:

877.528.7878

888.239.3909

First Chicago Logo

Phone:

First Chicago Insurance Company

Claims:

888.262.8864

888.262.8864

Foremost Insurance Logo

Phone:

Foremost Insurance Group

Claims:

888.888.0080

800.527.3905

Founders Insurance Logo

Phone:

Founders Insurance Company

Claims:

847.768.0040

888.676.4342

Nationwide Insurance Logo

Phone:

Nationwide Insurance

Claims:

877.669.6877

800.421.3535

Progressive Insurance Logo

Phone:

Progressive Insurance

Claims:

800.776.4737

800.274.4499

Travelers Logo

Phone:

Travelers

Claims:

800.842.5075

800.252.4633