top of page

MEET THE TEAM

Paul Clayton Jr.
Paul Clayton Jr.

Principal Agent

317-328-4444

317-863-1400

Paul, from Indianapolis, is an experienced sales consultant, with customer service, product and service sales, sales management, and account management. Having worked for Verizon for 8 years in several capacities, his experience makes him primed and well prepared to be an integral part of the Oldham Insurance Agency. Paul is father of three young girls, Nia, Zola, and Anya with his wife Sarah. He is the drummer for the music ministry at his church, Solid Word and has played with several groups and bands over the years. Paul is member of the 100 Black Men of Indianapolis, a service organization focused on mentoring and helping youth to be the leaders of tomorrow.

Sarah K. Clayton, CIC, CRM, CPRM
Sarah K. Clayton, CIC, CRM, CPRM

Agent

317-328-4444

317-863-1400

Sarah, an Indianapolis native, is an experienced insurance professional who grew up in the industry. She earned her property and casualty insurance license while completing her Bachelors in Public Relations from Ball State and her life and health license after graduation. Sarah worked in her father’s agency in several capacities until his retirement. Since having earned her Certified Insurance Counselor, Certified Risk Manager and Certified Personal Risk Manager designations she is excited to utilize her deeper knowledge of exposures and insurance solutions to help clients make informed decisions.

Donald Oldham, III, CIC
Donald Oldham, III, CIC

Principal Agent

317-328-4444

317-863-1400

Donald is from Indianapolis, a proud graduate of North Central High School where he starred on the North Central Soccer, state champion team. He holds a B.S. in finance from Clark H. Byrum School of Business at Marian University, where he played collegiate soccer as well. Donald worked as an insurance producer for an exclusive insurance agency right out of college prior to starting Oldham Insurance. He was under the tutelage of his father, Donald Oldham, Jr. who has over 30 years of industry experience. Donald holds his Certified Insurance Counselor designation, which is one the most prestigious designations in the insurance industry. In his downtime, he enjoys playing and coaching soccer, playing golf, and reading.

bottom of page